Our Case Studies

£40,000 for local man who underwent unnecessary surgery at Castle Hill Hospital, Hull

A 58-year-old man was referred by his GP to Castle Hill Hospital with rising PSA (Prostate Specific Antigen) levels. On 26.8.08, biopsies of the prostate were obtained. Upon examination of the biopsies by a histopathologist, he reported these to show signs of a moderately aggressive cancer. After being told of the diagnosis of prostate cancer and following consideration of the possible treatment options, our client agreed to elective surgery. On 21.11.08, a radical prostatectomy (removal of entire prostate gland and seminal vesicles) was performed.

On 12.1.09, a different histopathologist examined our client’s 5 operative biopsies. Surprisingly, none of these revealed any evidence of cancer. Following further investigation, it became apparent that a major mistake had occurred in the pathology laboratory at the Hull Royal Infirmary and 2 patients’ pathology biopsies had been incorrectly labelled. In actual fact, our client’s biopsies were negative for cancer and he had therefore undergone an unnecessary operation. As a result of this he suffered ongoing problems with bladder function and erectile dysfunction.

We agreed to act under a “No Win, No Fee” agreement from the beginning, at no financial cost to our client. Within 3½ months a full admission of liability was obtained from the Hospital. In less than 11 months, we negotiated a settlement of £40,000 for our client and he was very happy with this. If you would like us to help you, just send us a quick email, pop in to see us or call our free telephone number - 0800 298 6013. We offer a free first interview, so you have nothing to lose.

Pathology reporting: Background information

A histopathologist looks at tissues and cells removed from patients in the clinic or during an operation. The tissue is first examined with the naked eye to look for any visible abnormalities and to select pieces to examine in more detail. These small pieces are treated so that very thin slices can be cut. The slices are then looked at under a microscope and the histopathologist tells the patient’s doctor what is wrong and often provide crucial information about the correct treatment. If any mistakes occur, patients may undergo unnecessary surgery or not receive the treatment that they need. Histopathologists are the people who diagnose cancers and other serious illnesses.

Go back to the top

Go back to Case Studies