fbpx Skip to main content
CALL US: 01482 323 697
Williamsons News

Who Should Pay For Injured Employees?

18 April 2013

News, Personal Injury

On 9th October 2012 the Government published a list of amendments to the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill that has been working its way through Parliament. Amongst the proposals was an amendment to section 47 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 to “remove the right of individuals to bring a claim for breach of a statutory duty contained in health and safety regulations. This means in future, in such cases, it will only be possible for an individual to bring a civil action on the basis that the employer has been negligent”.

At present, the regulatory regime provides that where an employee is found to be in breach of Health and Safety Regulations, it will automatically follow that an employer will be liable for any injuries sustained by an employee as a result of that breach. For instance, Regulation 5 of the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998 states that “Every employer shall ensure that work equipment is maintained in an efficient state, in efficient working order and in good repair”. At the present time, if an employee is injured due to faulty work equipment they will automatically succeed with a claim against their employer, as the employer will have failed to ensure that the work equipment provided by them was in good repair and efficient working order.

If the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill is passed in its current form, an employee would not only have to show that the work equipment was faulty, but they would also have to demonstrate that the problem with the work equipment was the result of the negligence of their employer. If an employer is able to demonstrate that they carried out appropriate inspections to ensure that the work equipment was safe, and that the work equipment developed a fault in any event, an employer may be able to escape liability.

An employee can often sustain severe injuries due to faulty work equipment, and it may be the case that they require treatment medical treatment and/or care for the rest of their life. An employee who is injured during the course of work, due to faulty equipment supplied by their employer, will no longer have a right to damages unless they can also show that the defect was caused by the employer’s negligence. This principle also extends to employees who are injured due to a defective workplace, or those who are injured due to an inadequate system of work.

The Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill does not indicate who will be responsible for paying for the medical treatment or care needs of an employee who is injured in a scenario similar to the above. At the present time the cost of any such medical treatment or care would fall on the employer’s insurance providers. If the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill is passed then the cost of such medical treatment or care will have to be met by the injured employee and the National Health Service.

The Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill will, in many cases, shift the burden of responsibility for an accident at work from the employer to the employee. The burden has been shifted from the employer, who in the majority of circumstances is in the best position to take on such a responsibility, to the employee who may be low paid and be in a poor position to pay for any medical treatment or care that they require.

The House of Lords completed their third reading of the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill on 20th March 2013. The Bill has now been returned to the House of Commons for their final reading.

The Bill was debated on the floor of the House of Commons on 16th April 2013. During that debate Chuka Umunna, the Shadow Business Secretary, commented:

“I shall move on to deal with health and safety. Clause 61, to which Lords amendments 38 and 39 apply, is designed to remove civil liability for breaches of duty imposed by health and safety regulations. In so doing, it overturns an accepted and established health and safety regime that has been on the statute book for a very long time—for over a century.

The MP Andy McDonald added:

“…as a result of the failure of cases that would otherwise have succeeded, people who have not received compensation will look to the statutory authorities for their rehabilitation—for their care, speech therapy and physiotherapy—and that that will effectively constitute the nationalisation of rehabilitation”.

The Bill will be given further consideration on the floor of the House of Commons on 22nd April 2013.

Contact Us Back to top
Read some reviews from our clients

4.89 Average

175 Reviews

Mr and Mrs Preston

Williamson’s provide an excellent service at a reasonable price. Very easy to deal with and excellent communication was provided all the way through the transaction. Just what you need in a solicitor.


I would highly recommend Williamsons Solicitors, Gordon represented me for my case and was excellent. Always on the end of the phone when I need him. overall top job thankyou. Mr Lloyd Milner

Mr & M

Very friendly and efficient service always replying to any queries and emails on the same day. If solicitor not in still dealt with by other staff. Would definitely recommend and will use again

Mr Andrew W

They have handled my house moving with professionalism and friendliness and kept in touch regularly to keep me updated I would strongly recommend them 👍

Mr Deeley

Very good service from everyone I dealt with at Williamson's. They were very quick and responsive and gave that extra push to get me completed before the Christmas holiday! A very nice Christmas present for me!

Mr E A

Very good service.

John B

Friendly service straight to the point no messing around ... from start to finish less then 4 month Yana had every thing in hand many thanks

Mr and Mrs Rollinson

Excellent service from start to finish Alison Craven explained everything in detail making sure we understood

Broadley H

Excellent service from Williamsons throughout a very protracted property transaction. Carey was patient and helpful at all times and we would highly recommend Williamsons based upon our experience. Thank you :)

Paul B

Hi, Thankyou for helping me with the sale of my late mothers house. You kept me informed and processed the transaction very quickly. Regards...Paul

Mr William E

Williamsons Bridlington office conducted the conveyancing of my house recently. The customer service was exceptional and very professional. The regular communications were very helpful and i was kept up to date throughout the process. Many thanks to Suzanne, Beth and all the staff at the Bridlington office.


Friendly supportive service. Explained everything and responded to queries promptly


Its always difficult when you are selling a house but even more so when it is a probate sale. Williamsons have handled my sale with sensitivity and efficiency and have supported me throughout the process.

Mr & M

Very efficient, prompt replies to queries, show good team work and a very reasonable bill at the end.

Mr D A

I was given an efficient, friendly and courteous appointment.

Mr and Mrs Lang

Thorough and commendable.

Mr & M

Professional,helpful and friendly staff we use Williamson's for all legal matters.

Mrs Yvonne K

Suzanne Spooner was excellent. She kept me informed of progress and the whole stressful process of selling one’s house went as smoothly as possible.

Miss L

We were very impressed by Theresa's thorough approach. We are very confident that our conveyancing was carried out to perfection.

Sarah B

Fantastic service from Susan and her team dealing with the sale of the house. Easily contactable for any queries and would definitely recommend them.

Andrew H

Very thorough, helpful throughout and ensured no undue delays.