fbpx Skip to main content
CALL US: 01482 323 697
Shipping & Transport
Shipping & Transport Badge
Shipping & Transport

Fishing Vessels: Caution to be exercised with VMS Data

Fishing Vessels: Caution to be exercised with VMS Data

Under EU legislation, fishing vessels in EU coastal countries are required to have a Vessel Monitoring System (VMS) which, at regular intervals, provides the fisheries authorities with details of the vessels location, speed and course.

In July this year, four Devon scallop fishermen faced prosecution at the Gloucester Crown Court for allegedly fishing within prohibited areas in the offshore limit in January and February 2016. The Devon and Severn Inshore Conservation Authority who have jurisdiction over this area brought the prosecution on the basis of VMS data received during that time.

Whilst it was not denied, at the material time, the vessels were located in prohibited areas; the fishermen maintained that the fishing gear was not being used.

Evidence of the prevailing sea and weather conditions were produced as being conducive to good fishing conditions, but the prosecution case ultimately relied upon VMS data. Although, the vessels were fitted with Automatic Identification System (AIS), these were not in operation at the time and the Authority argued that this was a further attempt to conceal illegal fishing.

Whilst evidence of speed, conditions and position are often suggestive of fishing activity, the intermittent readings by the VMS equipment alone were insufficient to prove that the fishermen had fished in prohibited areas and accordingly, they were acquitted.

It was undoubtedly in the public interest to pursue such a case but with the level of reliance on VMS data, it is surprising that the Authority considered this to be sufficient to provide a realistic prospect of conviction.

That said, unless a fisherman is caught in the act, these cases are often very difficult to prove and perhaps the decision to pursue the case was influenced by a desire to gauge the weight of VMS evidence in Court. It is important to convict the guilty but far more important to ensure the innocent are not convicted.

If you have any Shipping & Transport enquiries and would like to get in contact with our Maritime expert Gordon Sewell, contact us on 01482 323697.

W

Get in touch:
Contact Us Back to top
Read some reviews from our clients

4.89 Average

164 Reviews

Anonymous

Friendly supportive service. Explained everything and responded to queries promptly

Anonymous

Its always difficult when you are selling a house but even more so when it is a probate sale. Williamsons have handled my sale with sensitivity and efficiency and have supported me throughout the process.

Mr & M

Very efficient, prompt replies to queries, show good team work and a very reasonable bill at the end.

Mr D A

I was given an efficient, friendly and courteous appointment.

Mr and Mrs Lang

Thorough and commendable.

Mr & M

Professional,helpful and friendly staff we use Williamson's for all legal matters.

Mrs Yvonne K

Suzanne Spooner was excellent. She kept me informed of progress and the whole stressful process of selling one’s house went as smoothly as possible.

Miss L

We were very impressed by Theresa's thorough approach. We are very confident that our conveyancing was carried out to perfection.

Sarah B

Fantastic service from Susan and her team dealing with the sale of the house. Easily contactable for any queries and would definitely recommend them.

Andrew H

Very thorough, helpful throughout and ensured no undue delays.

Mr Nicholls

Once again a smooth transaction thanks to Beth at Williamsons. Will certainly be using again. Thanks

Mr and Mrs Allgood

We were delighted with the service we received. Each time it was necessary to make contact we received a prompt response. As existing clients we would not hesitate to use this service again.

Anonymous

We instructed Williamsons to carry out the conveyancing on our house purchase. Gemma was excellent, keeping us up to date with the progress made towards completion by email and sending us the relevant paper work. She made us aware of any issues and suggested a course of action. We would highly recommend using Williamsons.

Mrs Ward

Jane Cousins and her colleagues were absolutely brilliant! They were extremely patient and helpful and kept us up to date by email whenever necessary!! She promised to hold my hand through the process of buying and selling our homes and certainly did! We cannot thank her and Emma and Rebecca enough!!! Thank you all very much!! Sheilah/Owen Ward

Ms D

Very happy with the service provided both on my sale and purchase. Thank you

Dr P

Straightforward, efficient, clear, well-informed.

Mr Francis

Exemplary service. Kept me up to date throughout the process. Carefully explained any difficulties or technical issues. Brilliant service

Anonymous

Very helpful & prompt service! Nothing was too much trouble. Can highly recommend

Mr and Mrs Jarvis

Handled our sale and purchase extremely well, first class.

Mr and Mrs Green

We were delighted with the service we received. Although unable to speak to our designated officer Mrs Spooner, her assistant Natalie was always on hand to advise, particularly relevant on the final day when exchange and completion took place at the same time. A difficult period, not being helped by the long-distance, was made as easy as such a situation could ever be. Thank you.

Mrs Margaret W

I am new to Williamsons, my first time with them. It’s been a positive efficient and friendly experience. So much so that I won’t be going any where else in future. Thank you to all at Williamsons!