Routine Inspections
The council can usually easily show this by carrying out routine inspections of the highway and repairing any defects they are aware of, within a reasonable time. As there are no set guidelines for what is deemed a reasonable routine of inspection, it is all too common that these inspections are insufficient to identify those defects which would be actionable, had they been identified. This is often because they are carried out by a single inspector driving along the road.
It is clear to see that as well as it being difficult for the inspector to spot defects from the inside of a vehicle, whilst concentrating on driving, the addition of parked cars can contribute to many defects not being picked up on and repaired. Despite this, the fact that the inspection was carried out is often sufficient for the council to successfully avoid liability and awarding the injured party the compensation they deserve.
Reporting a Defect
Another aspect of this is often that the council will claim they were not aware that the defect which caused the claimant to fall, as no one had reported it to them; i.e. how could they be expected to repair something they did not know was a problem.
This has the effect of placing the responsibility of reporting problems with the highways upon the general public.
Is the Defect Actionable?
Another common difficulty is establishing that the defect was of a size which would warrant repair. It is of course understandable that requiring the council to repair all defects, even those which are minor, would be unreasonable and divert valuable funds away from other important public services.
In all cases of personal injury it is for the injured party to prove their claim, not the council to disprove. Therefore it is very important that if you were unfortunate enough to be injured because of a defect on the highway, you should take photographs of the cause, which clearly shows the depth and location of the defect. In doing so, we would recommend that, as well as taking photographs with something placed within the defect (i.e. for example a 50p coin to give perspective) you also take photographs which would show the defects in its surroundings, such as street names or house numbers.
Who can help
When faced with these difficulties it is important that you have an experienced lawyer on your side; who is aware not only of the difficulties in winning such cases, but also the work and diligence required to overturn any denial of liability and who is willing to take the time to carefully inspect the records kept by the council and put to them the difficult questions which may reveal the inadequacies within their systems of inspection or repair procedures.
At Williamsons Solicitors, we have successfully recovered compensation for Claimants in such cases.
Recent example
The most recent inspection had also recorded that the defect was at a level which would be considered as dangerous and requiring repair. Despite this the council claimed that they had carried out a reasonable inspection, had taken steps to avoid the accident from happening and had repaired the defect within a reasonable time. Our response was to point out that the council were fully aware, not only of the defect, but also that the same was dangerous and posed a risk to the general public on a busy, but poorly lit highway, and that they had failed to take any steps to repair the defect or to warn the public of the danger it posed.
Although we fully appreciate the pressure upon the council to carry out repairs, and that it can be difficult to do so quickly, a simple and cost effective way of avoiding our client’s accident would have been to mark the defect with coloured spray paint, or to have placed signs over the defect to make her aware that it was present and to be avoided.
The council carried out further investigation, and conceded that they had failed in their duty of care and that our client was entitled to an aware of compensation for her injuries.
If you have found yourself in a similar situation or would simply like some advice, get in touch with our specialist team now on 01482 323697 or contact us through our form below.
We are raising money for Dove House Hospice by selling raffle tickets to win a wonderful Easter Egg! Event has… Read More
Many of our clients who become involved in court proceedings of any sort concerning the arrangements for children will encounter… Read More
A blog by Blue Stephenson, Solicitor in the Family Department at Williamsons. If you are contemplating getting a… Read More
We are delighted to announce that Williamsons Solicitors have been approved to join the Headway Injury Solicitors Directory. Headway is… Read More
Cancer is a disease that no one want to hear they have, however the NHS report that 1 in 2… Read More
Please not the office closes at 12pm on Friday 22nd December 2023. We re-open at 8:00am in Hull & 8:45… Read More