fbpx Skip to main content
CALL US: 01482 323 697
Williamsons News

Pursuing a public highways claim against the Council

28 November 2019

Blog, Personal Injury

The state of the public highways is a well-known and often complained about problem, especially in this age of austerity; and repairs of potholes and other defects are routinely not being carried out as efficiently as we would expect.

Where those defects are the cause of, sometimes severe, injuries it can be difficult to prove that the local council has been at fault for causing the injuries. The main reason for this is that the Court have been reluctant to impose liability on a local council.

Routine Inspections

Personal Injury - Williamsons SolicitorsIn order to avoid liability, the council must be able to show that they have complied with their duties under s58 Highways Act 1980; put simply, the requirements are that the council take reasonable steps to avoid accidents from happening.

The council can usually easily show this by carrying out routine inspections of the highway and repairing any defects they are aware of, within a reasonable time. As there are no set guidelines for what is deemed a reasonable routine of inspection, it is all too common that these inspections are insufficient to identify those defects which would be actionable, had they been identified. This is often because they are carried out by a single inspector driving along the road.

It is clear to see that as well as it being difficult for the inspector to spot defects from the inside of a vehicle, whilst concentrating on driving, the addition of parked cars can contribute to many defects not being picked up on and repaired. Despite this, the fact that the inspection was carried out is often sufficient for the council to successfully avoid liability and awarding the injured party the compensation they deserve.

Reporting a Defect

Another aspect of this is often that the council will claim they were not aware that the defect which caused the claimant to fall, as no one had reported it to them; i.e. how could they be expected to repair something they did not know was a problem.

This has the effect of placing the responsibility of reporting problems with the highways upon the general public.

Is the Defect Actionable?

Another common difficulty is establishing that the defect was of a size which would warrant repair. It is of course understandable that requiring the council to repair all defects, even those which are minor, would be unreasonable and divert valuable funds away from other important public services.

Personal Injury - Williamsons SolicitorsThere is no set guideline for how deep a defect must be before the council have a duty to repair it; however, the generally accepted level is around 1 inch.

In all cases of personal injury it is for the injured party to prove their claim, not the council to disprove. Therefore it is very important that if you were unfortunate enough to be injured because of a defect on the highway, you should take photographs of the cause, which clearly shows the depth and location of the defect. In doing so, we would recommend that, as well as taking photographs with something placed within the defect (i.e. for example a 50p coin to give perspective) you also take photographs which would show the defects in its surroundings, such as street names or house numbers.

Who can help

When faced with these difficulties it is important that you have an experienced lawyer on your side; who is aware not only of the difficulties in winning such cases, but also the work and diligence required to overturn any denial of liability and who is willing to take the time to carefully inspect the records kept by the council and put to them the difficult questions which may reveal the inadequacies within their systems of inspection or repair procedures.

At Williamsons Solicitors, we have successfully recovered compensation for Claimants in such cases.

Recent example

Helen LennonIn a recent case involving our client, a thorough inspection of the records provided by the council to support their denial of liability, revealed that the council had in fact seen the defect at inspections three months before the accident and also less than one month before.

The most recent inspection had also recorded that the defect was at a level which would be considered as dangerous and requiring repair. Despite this the council claimed that they had carried out a reasonable inspection, had taken steps to avoid the accident from happening and had repaired the defect within a reasonable time. Our response was to point out that the council were fully aware, not only of the defect, but also that the same was dangerous and posed a risk to the general public on a busy, but poorly lit highway, and  that they had failed to take any steps to repair the defect or to warn the public of the danger it posed.

Although we fully appreciate the pressure upon the council to carry out repairs, and that it can be difficult to do so quickly, a simple and cost effective way of avoiding our client’s accident would have been to mark the defect with coloured spray paint, or to have placed signs over the defect to make her aware that it was present and to be avoided.

The council carried out further investigation, and conceded that they had failed in their duty of care and that our client was entitled to an aware of compensation for her injuries.

If you have found yourself in a similar situation or would simply like some advice, get in touch with our specialist team now on 01482 323697 or contact us through our form below.

Please only press the send button once

*required fields
**Mon-Fri only

Contact Us Back to top
Read some reviews from our clients

4.89 Average

175 Reviews

Mr and Mrs Preston

Williamson’s provide an excellent service at a reasonable price. Very easy to deal with and excellent communication was provided all the way through the transaction. Just what you need in a solicitor.


I would highly recommend Williamsons Solicitors, Gordon represented me for my case and was excellent. Always on the end of the phone when I need him. overall top job thankyou. Mr Lloyd Milner

Mr & M

Very friendly and efficient service always replying to any queries and emails on the same day. If solicitor not in still dealt with by other staff. Would definitely recommend and will use again

Mr Andrew W

They have handled my house moving with professionalism and friendliness and kept in touch regularly to keep me updated I would strongly recommend them 👍

Mr Deeley

Very good service from everyone I dealt with at Williamson's. They were very quick and responsive and gave that extra push to get me completed before the Christmas holiday! A very nice Christmas present for me!

Mr E A

Very good service.

John B

Friendly service straight to the point no messing around ... from start to finish less then 4 month Yana had every thing in hand many thanks

Mr and Mrs Rollinson

Excellent service from start to finish Alison Craven explained everything in detail making sure we understood

Broadley H

Excellent service from Williamsons throughout a very protracted property transaction. Carey was patient and helpful at all times and we would highly recommend Williamsons based upon our experience. Thank you :)

Paul B

Hi, Thankyou for helping me with the sale of my late mothers house. You kept me informed and processed the transaction very quickly. Regards...Paul

Mr William E

Williamsons Bridlington office conducted the conveyancing of my house recently. The customer service was exceptional and very professional. The regular communications were very helpful and i was kept up to date throughout the process. Many thanks to Suzanne, Beth and all the staff at the Bridlington office.


Friendly supportive service. Explained everything and responded to queries promptly


Its always difficult when you are selling a house but even more so when it is a probate sale. Williamsons have handled my sale with sensitivity and efficiency and have supported me throughout the process.

Mr & M

Very efficient, prompt replies to queries, show good team work and a very reasonable bill at the end.

Mr D A

I was given an efficient, friendly and courteous appointment.

Mr and Mrs Lang

Thorough and commendable.

Mr & M

Professional,helpful and friendly staff we use Williamson's for all legal matters.

Mrs Yvonne K

Suzanne Spooner was excellent. She kept me informed of progress and the whole stressful process of selling one’s house went as smoothly as possible.

Miss L

We were very impressed by Theresa's thorough approach. We are very confident that our conveyancing was carried out to perfection.

Sarah B

Fantastic service from Susan and her team dealing with the sale of the house. Easily contactable for any queries and would definitely recommend them.

Andrew H

Very thorough, helpful throughout and ensured no undue delays.