fbpx Skip to main content
CALL US: 01482 323 697
Williamsons News
News

Remote Hearings – Unfair?

9 December 2020

Family and Childcare, News

Sarah Clubley of Williamsons Solicitors and all family solicitors in their offices in Hull, Driffield, Bridlington and Beverley have undertaken remote hearings during the pandemic.

Sarah has undertaken remote hearings where new mothers have had their babies taken into care during remote video and telephone hearings from hospitals.

Williamsons Solicitors - Family and ChildcareParents are joining online proceedings from home often without adequate technology or support, when life-changing decisions are made about their children.  Almost half of the parents and relatives involved in Family Court hearings during the crisis said they did not understand well what was happening.

There have been instances where litigants have appeared remotely in their pyjamas or whilst still in bed.

A recent report by the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory concluded that even before the pandemic struck in March there was a debate about whether remote hearings delivered justice.  Cuts to legal aid mean that since 2013 many litigants are no longer represented in family courts.

The report says problems experienced included ‘parents taking part in hearings remotely, alone and from their homes, lack of communication between parties and their legal representatives’ and communication difficulties during hearings.

Williamsons Solicitors - Family and ChildcareMost parents joined by phone rather than video link.  Those who needed an interpreter or who had disabilities faced particularly severe challenges.

The most difficult cases were those in which social services believed babies needed to be taken into care under an interim order shortly after birth.  They on occasions involved a mother joining the hearing by a phone from hospital.  Previously they were likely to have been represented by a solicitor in court.

‘There is nothing fair about a remote hearing which requires you to remove a newborn baby from its mother’.  ‘Remote hearings do not enable you to show empathy’.

The report says ‘mothers have frequently not been able to have any physical contact with their babies following their removal’ during the pandemic because of fears over infection.

One Judge expressed significant reservations about remote hearings for such sensitive cases.  ‘Removing children and making major decisions can have lifelong consequences.  Notwithstanding everyone’s best efforts, remote parties cannot sometimes be adequately engaged.  I have real misgivings about how fair it is and how fair it is felt and seen to be’.

Another remarked ‘I worry about making orders which may be very distressing to a participant, e.g. the removal of their child.  In court they’d at least have a lawyer with whom they could grieve, rant, consider appeal and have support.  By phone or video, they may be in their bedroom, alone and in despair, perhaps with the child and now awaiting a visit from a social worker’.

Sarah ClubleyAmong other responses was one from a Judge who said ‘My morale has massively improved since I started doing [physical] hearings again’.  Upholding the authority of the family court was also considered harder to sustain online.  One Magistrate heard a case where a litigant was plastering.

There was some more positive reactions, in particular the fact that hearings are now subject to a time slot and finish in that time slot is welcome and the days of sitting at court all day waiting to get on for 5 minutes appear to be over.

The President of the Family Division of the High Court, said ‘This emergency is without precedent.  Judges and others (solicitors and the courts) have worked tirelessly, and continue to do so, so that the family courts have continued to function without a break since the start of lockdown.

Sarah says anyone who is given notice of a remote hearing should contact the offices of Williamsons Solicitors on 01482 323697.


Contact Us Back to top
Read some reviews from our clients

4.89 Average

207 Reviews

Mr Psaras

Friendly, efficient and exceptional service. I will use another of their services soon. Highly recommended.

K S

During a worldwide pandemic Williamsons were superb, i was kept up to date with proceedings, costs, future expectations etc. Using all forms of communiction including Email, telephone, face to face, video chat the knowledge and expertise is second to none and i wouldn't hesitate to use again should i require. I would highly recommend Williamsons for any legal matters their professionalism and helpfulness made my case much smoother, together with the ability to pay stage by stage i cannot stress how great the service was, needless to say my case was resolved to my expectations. I would urge anyone to use Williamsons for legal advice an easy 5 stars with special mention to Paul, Karen and Claire for the service i received from them.

Ms L

I chose Theresa and Toni at Williamsons again for this property purchase because of the care, attention to detail and professionalism they demonstrated last year when I bought another property. I have received a marvellous service again and I feel confident that they will have carefully looked at every detail of the necessary documentation involved in the buying process. Geographically, Williamsons is a long way from the property I have just bought but firms like Williamsons are a rarity and worth seeking out. I thoroughly recommend this company.

Mr & M

Wet happy with the comprehensive and personal service Thank you

Mr and Mrs Betts

Excellent client service- professional and courteous. Thank you to Madeleine.

Anonymous

I chose Williamsons to act as my conveyancers and I have been super impressed with their professionalism and ethics to act on behalf of their client. My process was a long one, due to no fault on Williamsons part, but they never dropped the ball and continued to chase the other party until we got the answers we needed. I would choose them again in a heart beat and recommend their services.

Mr T W

Fantastic service from Williamsons Solicitors especially Rachael Scott who handled everything brilliantly from start to finish. Thank you

Mr Beevers

Happy with the work done on my behalf

Mrs T D

Hello, I had a lovely experience at Williamsons. Alison and Katie made everything really easy for me and were really helpful 2really nice people.

Anonymous

Brilliant service from Williamsons. Very efficient and quick responses to any questions or queries I had. Would highly recommend.

Anonymous

Excellent 5* service. We tragically lost our daughter and we found Williamsons Solicitors who guided us through all the claim process. They are extremely knowledgeable and professional with a personal style that made the journey more manageable. There communication is always prompt. Thoroughly recommend Wayne Walker.

A G

I can well recommend, I have received professional and honest service which lead to positive closure of the case. Always responded with care and fully involvement which gave me more confidence to continue. All advices during the progressing of the case was competent and mirrored current situation.

Mrs Hughes

The conveyancing team were excellent, extremely helpful and made sure that I felt valued at all times. A big thank you

Brian S

We would like to thank Gordon for his assistance and reassurance in dealing with the problem regarding the boundary hedge. His professionalism and manner are a credit to the company and we would certainly recommend him to friends.

Miss B

Beth Dyson and colleagues have been excellent during the purchase of my new house. Very responsive to email and phone queries, polite and professional, and the sale has been completed in 13 weeks from acceptance of the offer to completion. Given the current COVID-19 situation and how that has impacted on everyone, that's great. Thanks to everyone at Williamsons for making buying my new home so straightforward!

Miss S

Excellent service from Beth Dyson despite all the pressures of the Covid lockdown. Beth carried out conveyancing of my sale and purchase very thoroughly and efficiently with good communication and always in a helpful and friendly manner. Many thanks.

Joanna H

Well from the moment I met Wayne Walker his professionalism,clarity of thought, and aim to do the best job he can were all evident. He has been involved with my family for five years nearly and has always made me feel as though my views were relevant and integral to furthering the case. Wayne has highly developed organisational skills and we always felt just ‘looked after’ by Wayne snd Williamsons in getting through the very worst of times. Wayne sometimes needed to encourage me to look at things from a different perspective and he always achieved this with firm kindness. Wayne is a great professional but more importantly a fundamentally great human being. I will always recommend Williamsons and especially on the subject of clinical negligence I will always recommend Wayne. Full job well done start to finish. Thanks Wayne there are no words. Jo Hogg (Polly’s mum)

Anonymous

Williamsons Solicitors supported our family to succeed to a very high level. We cannot thank Sarah Jackson enough for her incredible support, dedication and commitment to understanding the finest detail of our case. Her dedication was phonememonal and we wouldn't hesitate to recommend her in a heartbeat. Thank you for bringing closure to our case and for supporting us one hundred percent. We were informed at every stage within the case and knew we were in safe professional hands throughout. Many thanks, Mr and Mrs Appleton.

Asoka T

Very professional and a friendly team, specially Helen Lennon who handled my case.

Carl R

I was very happy with the way they handled my case and still got the result even in these hard times where having at the moment thank you to all involved and I’d recommend you to others

Angie L

Williamsons solicitors were professional, caring and efficient. They dealt with what was, a very upsetting experience I had via medical negligence. They kept me up to date, enquired about my well-being and were always available to either speak to me when I had concerns or answered my emails. They ensured that the compensation I finally received was in my best interests by advising what they thought was a too low first offer of settlement. I cannot thank them enough for the way they handled my case and for pushing for a better higher settlement figure. I would definitely use them again should I ever be in a position to need them Thank you so much.